14 State AGs Reinforce Disparate Impact Liability In Their Jurisdictions
A coalition of 14 state Attorneys General (AGs) recently issued guidance that disparate impact liability is alive and well in their jurisdictions.
“The federal government has recently targeted longstanding civil rights protections, falsely describing them as ‘illegal’ in executive orders, agency memoranda and guidance, grant terms and conditions, and the media,” the AGs of California, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Mexico, New York, Oregon, Vermont and Washington wrote. “These actions only sow confusion for our constituents – the workers, students, tenants, homebuyers, health care patients, and many other community members these laws are designed to protect. Neither the President nor federal agencies can rewrite laws passed by Congress, nor use executive orders or agency rules or memoranda to change protections provided under the Constitution or federal or state laws.”
In the Multistate Guidance on Antidiscrimination Protections, the AGs detailed the history of disparate impact liability, dating back to the New Deal, and citing the U.S. Supreme Court’s 1971 decision in Griggs v. Duke Power Co., where the justices “recognized that it did not matter whether the policy was created with the intention to discriminate against Black people, because the policy had a discriminatory effect.”
Since then, cases brought under a disparate impact theory of liability have consistently succeeded in the federal courts under various statutes, according to the guidance, including Title VII and the Fair Housing Act.
The enforcement of disparate impact liability increases opportunity across many sectors and taking proactive measures to remove unjustified barriers and ensure more equitable opportunities is legal, cost effective and benefits everyone, the AGs added, providing a list of “promising policies and practices” that can proactively further the goals of civil rights laws in both the public and private sectors.
In the context of employment, the guidance suggested establishing clear and transparent policies and practices for recruitment, hiring, retention, advancement and termination with buy-in from all levels of leadership in the analysis, planning, implementation and evaluation.
Employers should also ensure qualifications and criteria for recruitment, hiring, retention, advancement and termination are standardized, focused on skills and experience relevant to the job, and communicated clearly.
Providing equal access to all aspects of professional development, training and mentorship programs that provide clear pathways for growth was also suggested by the guidance, as well as creating clear protocols for reporting discrimination or harassment and more general communication and feedback loops for employees to provide information about their experiences in the workplace.
“[O]ur civil rights laws prevent unjustified disparate impacts – when actions appear neutral on their face, but unnecessarily and unfairly harm or exclude groups of people in practice, even when more inclusive or less harmful options are available,” the AGs wrote. “Disparate impact liability is a longstanding, constitutional tool intended to ensure fairness and equal opportunity for everyone living in this country.”
To read the AG’s guidance, .
Why it matters: The AGs expressed concern about the federal government’s disavowal of disparate impact liability, including seeking to eliminate the use of disparate impact liability, as well as finding that EEOC’s disparate impact regulations and guidance are unconstitutional. The guidance emphasized that efforts to enforce civil rights protections—including disparate impact liability—are legal and effective and noted that the “future of our civil rights laws is at stake.”