Employer Not Strictly Liable for Non-Supervisor, California Appellate Court Rules

Where an alleged sexual harasser is not the plaintiff’s supervisor and only supervises other employees, strict liability for the employer does not apply, according to a California appellate panel.

A wealth adviser for Wells Fargo, Jane Doe alleged that a coworker sexually harassed and assaulted her on a business trip to Bakersfield.

The alleged harasser, although Doe viewed him as “a superior” with “power and influence,” was not her supervisor. He had no power to hire or fire employees or to approve their expenses or requests for time off.

When Doe reported her allegations, Wells Fargo investigated and concluded that her allegations were unsubstantiated.

Doe filed suit against Wells Fargo, her alleged harasser and other individuals, asserting claims of sexual harassment.

Wells Fargo moved for summary judgment and the trial court granted the motion. Doe appealed.

Under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), an employer is strictly liable for harassment by a supervisor, the court explained. For nonsupervisory employees, the employer is liable only if it was negligent in that it knew or should have known of the harassing conduct and failed to take immediate and appropriate corrective action.

“Wells Fargo is not strictly liable for harassment by [the alleged harasser] because the undisputed evidence established that [he] held no supervisory authority over [Doe] and he did not abuse his authority as an alleged supervisor in his actions toward [her],” the court wrote.

Doe conceded that the alleged harasser was not her supervisor. Instead, she relied on evidence purportedly showing he supervised support staff. But even assuming that he was a “supervisor” of other, lower-level employees, “Wells Fargo cannot be strictly liable for [the alleged harasser’s] conduct under the facts of this case,” the court said.

Contrary to Doe’s position, section 12940(j)(1) does not have an unmistakable plain meaning, the court found. The statute itself does not mention “strict liability,” and only in cases where the harasser is the plaintiff’s supervisor have the courts held that the statute, by implication, makes the employer strictly liable.

Section 12940(j)(1) can reasonably be interpreted to support Wells Fargo’s position, the court said, as whether an employee is a “supervisor” depends on that person’s relationship with other employees.

“When an employee supervises people other than the plaintiff and has no supervisory authority over the plaintiff, that employee’s role as a supervisor has no relevance to his or her relationship with the plaintiff,” the court wrote. “As to [Doe], the harasser is a coworker.”

Harassment by the plaintiff’s supervisor is “qualitatively worse” because of the power differential between the supervisor and the plaintiff and the potential for abuse, the court said. The alleged harasser’s role as a supervisor does not, by itself, create the power differential that exists between the plaintiff and her supervisor, and the employer has not vested the alleged harasser with authority to direct and manage the plaintiff on its behalf.

Doe’s interpretation of FEHA would create a rule “that imposes strict liability based on irrelevant facts and does not further the goals of FEHA,” the court wrote. “This is because whether the strict liability or negligence standard applies is untethered to the alleged harasser’s relationship with the plaintiff. Instead, the alleged harasser’s relationship with other employees determines which standard applies.”

While FEHA must be construed liberally to accomplish its purposes, that does not mean the court should interpret FEHA in a manner that would lead to arbitrary results disconnected with the purposes of the statutory scheme, the court said.

“If we were to adopt [Doe’s] position, an employer would be strictly liable for a mid-level manager’s sexual harassment of her own boss,” the court noted.

The court clarified that it was not holding that an employer can only be strictly liable for sexual harassment by the plaintiff’s direct or immediate supervisor or a supervisor successively higher in the employer’s hierarchy; the broad definition of supervisor stated in section 12926(t) makes others the plaintiff’s supervisor as well.

“But where, as here, the alleged harasser is not the plaintiff’s supervisor and only supervises other employees, strict liability does not apply,” the court held, affirming summary judgment for Wells Fargo.

To read the opinion in Doe v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., click .

Why it matters: The court declined to broaden its reading of FEHA and establish strict liability for employers where an alleged sexual harasser is not the plaintiff’s supervisor but supervises other employees—instead, the negligence standard applies.