Second Circuit: EFAA Enables Invalidation of Arbitration For All Claims
Joining the Sixth and Ninth Circuits, the Second U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals held that the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act (EFAA) enables a plaintiff to invalidate a pre-dispute arbitration agreement as to the entire lawsuit —not just the sexual harassment or assault claims within the action.
Silvia Diaz-Roa began working for Hermes Law in 2017 as an intern. She signed an arbitration agreement in 2018, agreeing to arbitrate any claims against the firm.
Over the next few years, Diaz-Roa was promoted multiple times, ultimately becoming the firm’s Director of Innovation. She and the founder of the firm also created ClaimDeck, a computerized litigation management company.
Although employed by Hermes Law, Diaz-Roa performed work for ClaimDeck and was awarded stock options of the company’s shares to reward her performance. By August 2023, her options were fully vested at a value exceeding $1 million.
Diaz-Roa expressed her intention to exercise her stock options in December 2023 but claimed she was terminated without warning shortly after.
In her subsequent lawsuit against the law firm, its founder and other individuals, Diaz-Roa asserted claims based on her stock options (breach of contract, deprivation of earned compensation in violation of New York law, tortious interference with contract and conversion), as well as sexual harassment.
She alleged that throughout her tenure, she was urged to flirt with prospective clients as a means of attracting business and encouraged to pursue romantic relationships with industry colleagues, and that the founder made recurring remarks about her physical appearance in front of other employees and allegedly compared her to a piece of steak at a dinner with colleagues.
The defendants moved to compel arbitration. Diaz-Roa invoked and the district court denied the motion.
On appeal, the defendants argued that the term “case,” as used in Section 402 of the EFAA, refers not to the lawsuit as a whole but rather to an individual claim within a lawsuit.
Under this reading, they maintained that when a complaint pleads a viable sexual harassment claim together with claims that are otherwise arbitrable, EFAA requires a court to set aside the arbitration agreement solely with respect to the harassment claim and those demonstrably related to it, while enforcing arbitration as to the remaining claims—even if doing so results in bifurcated proceedings.
The court disagreed.
“The operative language of the EFAA renders unenforceable any pre-dispute arbitration agreement ‘with respect to a case which … relates to [a] … sexual harassment dispute,’” the court said. “The word ‘case’ is read most naturally to refer to an entire lawsuit. The term is one of long familiarity and often operates as a commonplace descriptor for a judicial proceeding as a whole.”
By contrast, a claim “denotes something narrower, such as a singular ‘demand for money, property, or a legal remedy to which one asserts a right’ or ‘[a]n interest or remedy recognized at law.’”
Consistent with these definitions from Black’s Law Dictionary, the panel added that the U.S. Supreme Court and the Second Circuit frequently use the term “case” to refer to a lawsuit as a whole and the term “claim” to refer to a specific cause of action within that lawsuit.
In addition, EFAA’s drafters used the word “claim” instead of “case” elsewhere in the statute and the use of different words within the same statutory context strongly suggests that different meanings were intended.
“Accordingly, we conclude that ‘case’ in Section 402 plainly refers to a lawsuit as a whole, and thus, when a plaintiff successfully invokes EFAA to invalidate a pre-dispute arbitration agreement ‘with respect to a case which … relates to [a] … sexual harassment dispute,’ it invalidates the arbitration agreement as to all claims in that lawsuit, including any non-harassment claims,” the court held.
The only other circuits to consider the issue so far—the Sixth and —have reached the same conclusion.
Examining the defendants’ arguments to the contrary, the court was not persuaded.
The court did not improperly conflate the term “case” with the word “action,” and Article III’s limit of judicial power to “cases” and “controversies” did not mean the term “case” must be synonymous with the term “claim.”
Nor did the Federal Arbitration Act’s (FAA) general policy favoring arbitration help, as Congress expressly amended FAA in enacting EFAA and there was no need to delve into the legislative history of EFAA given the resolution based on the plain text of the statute, the panel said.
The Second Circuit held that Diaz-Roa could invalidate the arbitration agreement she signed with respect to not only her harassment claims, but to her entire lawsuit, affirming the denial of the defendants’ motion to compel arbitration.
To read the opinion in Diaz-Roa v. Hermes Law, click .
Why it matters: EFAA enables a plaintiff to invalidate a pre-dispute arbitration agreement as to the entire lawsuit—not just the sexual harassment or sexual assault claims within the lawsuit—the Second Circuit held, joining the other two federal appellate panels that have considered the issue.