Dynamic and Surveillance Pricing Moves From Study to Enforcement: What Businesses Need to Know

It is no secret that prices can, and do, change. A traveler checks a fare, comes back the next day, and finds it higher. Case studies have moved from algorithmic and dynamic pricing scenarios to surveillance pricing implicated personal data, the latter being the hot agenda item for regulators and private enforcers alike. Indeed, in just the past few months, the issue has moved quickly from study to enforcement. In August 2026, the Federal Trade Commission proposed a policy statement warning that undisclosed personalized pricing may violate Section 5. In October, it ordered nine major airlines, gig platforms and retailers to explain how they use personal data to set prices. Meanwhile states, and more recently, localities like Seattle are moving from disclosure mandates to outright bans, and plaintiffs are testing privacy, consumer protection, and antitrust theories in court. For businesses, from retailers to service providers, exposure now turns not only on the price charged, but on the data used to set it and what consumers are told about how prices are determined.

How Technology Changed Pricing

Pricing, particularly in the retail sector, used to run on seasonal markdowns and manual price changes. Today, AI tools weigh real-time data, from competitor prices and inventory to weather and consumer behavior and willingness to pay. As a result, online prices may shift several times a day or differ among consumers, while electronic shelf labels can update in sync. Some systems also model what each individual shopper is willing to pay.

Three terms are often used interchangeably but describe different practices. Dynamic pricing means consumers see the same price at a given time, with prices adjusting to market conditions. Algorithmic pricing means software sets or recommends the price, with or without personal data. Surveillance or personalized pricing uses consumer-specific data, such as purchase history, browsing behavior, location, or inferred characteristics, to set an individualized price. It is that last step, from market-level to individual-level pricing, that has drawn the attention of legislators, regulators and the plaintiffs’ bar.

Not all personalization carries the same risk. Loyalty and rewards discounts that consumers affirmatively join, with public and uniformly applied eligibility criteria, are exempt under most new laws. Hyper-personalization, where software predicts the exact discount or price needed for each shopper, is riskier, as is any personalization of essentials like groceries.

State and Local Law: From Disclosure to Prohibition

States have taken three approaches: requiring disclosure, banning the practice or both. The clear trend is toward prohibition, particularly for groceries and other essentials, and the definitions of “surveillance pricing” and “personal data” are consistently broad.

Disclosure. New York was first to act. Its Algorithmic Pricing Disclosure Act does not prohibit personalized pricing but requires businesses that use it to display the notice “THIS PRICE WAS SET BY AN ALGORITHM USING YOUR PERSONAL DATA,” with enforcement by the Attorney General and penalties of up to $1,000 per violation. A federal court rejected a First Amendment challenge to the law, which is now on appeal to the Second Circuit.

New York may soon go further. In June 2026, the legislature passed the One Fair Price Act, which, if signed by Governor Hochul, would replace the disclosure regime with a ban on surveillance pricing, subject to exceptions for bona fide loyalty, membership and rewards discounts.

Prohibition. Maryland, Connecticut, and New Jersey have enacted bans that take a market-by-market approach, targeting groceries, food delivery, and retail rather than the whole economy. Maryland’s law, in effect since October 1, 2026, bars food retailers and delivery providers from using personal data to raise grocery prices and from using “protected class data” to deny an advantage. Connecticut’s ban on surveillance pricing by retailers and delivery services takes effect July 1, 2027, and requires others to disclose data-driven price increases. New Jersey’s ban on personal-data pricing for groceries and household goods takes effect August 1, 2027, and the state has also paused new electronic shelf labels pending further study. Enforcement generally runs through the attorney general, though penalties vary widely and New Jersey’s law may allow private suits.

Local ordinances. Cities are now joining in. On October 5, 2026, Seattle became the first U.S. city to ban surveillance pricing when Mayor Katie Wilson signed the Fair Pricing and Transparency Ordinance (Ord. 127515). Effective September 1, 2027, the ordinance bars covered retailers from “algorithmic-based price discrimination,” meaning setting or altering the price of groceries and certain essential goods based on personal data or electronic surveillance technology, including random price variations. It covers grocers with 20 or more locations worldwide, larger mixed-use stores with grocery sections, and delivery services with 100 or more employees, and it reaches online prices, personalized in-store discounts, and electronic shelf labels. Covered retailers must disclose eligibility criteria for discounts and keep pricing records for three years. Notably, unlike most state laws, the ordinance creates a private right of action, including for classes, alongside City Attorney enforcement.

Just last week, the New York City Council approved legislation banning surveillance pricing (Int. No. 891-A). It prohibits any entity or service provider from engaging in surveillance pricing, defined as pricing set completely or in part by an algorithm that uses personal data to offer different prices to different customers for the same goods or services. The City Council announced that it is “among the strongest surveillance pricing bans in the country.” The prohibition is not industry-specific and includes exceptions and addresses permitted discounts. The legislation next goes to New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, whose administration has expressed support for this action, and the ban would take effect one year after becoming law.    

The result is a patchwork: the same pricing practice may be permitted in one jurisdiction, require disclosure in another and be prohibited in a third. National companies and retailers should expect to adapt practices or turn off features jurisdiction by jurisdiction, now at the city level as well as the state level, or consider a broader and uniform practice.

Discounts Versus Price Increases

One theme cuts across most of these laws, although their reach is less than clear: personalization that lowers prices is generally tolerated, while personalization that raises them is not. Most laws exempt loyalty, membership and rewards programs that consumers affirmatively join, as well as cost-justified differences, if eligibility is publicly disclosed and uniformly applied. Seattle preserves transparent discounts such as loyalty, senior, and veteran pricing, but still prohibits discounts tailored to an individual shopper.

Federal Scrutiny: From Policy Statement to 6(b) Orders

On August 19, 2026, the FTC proposed an enforcement policy statement providing that a business “should clearly and conspicuously disclose” personalized pricing whenever consumers would otherwise expect prices not to vary based on their data, explaining that the price is personalized, why and what data was used. Failing to do so, or collecting data for pricing without adequate disclosure or consent, could violate Section 5. Chairman Andrew Ferguson framed the concern simply: “When consumers see a listed price, they expect it to be the same price that everyone else sees.”

On October 28, 2026, the FTC escalated its focus. It issued Section 6(b) orders to nine companies seeking detailed information on how they use personal data, such as income and location, to set individualized prices, and, in the case of gig platforms, worker pay. The Commission said its 2024 study learned “nothing about actual pricing decisions” because it focused on pricing consultancies rather than the companies setting prices. Recipients have 45 days to respond, and the FTC can compel compliance in federal court.

The orders are broad. They reach back to January 1, 2023, and require a detailed description of every pricing “methodology” that uses personal information, including tools, inputs, and override rules, as well as consumer segmentation, third-party data and tools, A/B tests and pricing studies, cost-benefit analyses, and the wording and placement of every pricing disclosure. “Personal information” includes browsing history, reactions to advertising, and inferred willingness to pay, and “pricing” includes coupons, discounts, and promotions, so, read literally, the orders could reach loyalty and promotional programs.

In our view, although a 6(b) study has no specific law enforcement purpose, these responses will not stay in a vacuum. The narrative a company builds will likely shape later FTC enforcement, state attorney general inquiries, and private litigation, where plaintiffs already treat disclosures as admissions. The orders invite requests to narrow specifications and definitions, making the early meet-and-confer discussions with FTC staff a key opportunity to manage burden, set scope, and frame how loyalty and promotional programs, which most new laws exempt, are presented.

Businesses have pushed back. For example, in comments on the proposed policy statement, the Retail Industry Leaders Association argues that it does not clearly distinguish individualized price increases from loyalty discounts and ordinary algorithmic pricing, that treating silence as deception stretches Section 5, and that ambiguous guidance could fuel class actions and mass arbitrations under state laws that borrow FTC standards. Some companies are not waiting: in July 2026, Instacart publicly committed not to use personal information or real-time demand signals to set prices.

State Attorneys General

State attorneys general are moving too. California’s Attorney General launched an investigative sweep in January 2026 under the California Consumer Protection Act’s purpose-limitation principle, meaning businesses can potentially face exposure under existing privacy law even where no pricing ban exists. New York’s Attorney General has demanded information from an online grocery platform about its pricing experiments and invited consumers to report undisclosed algorithmic pricing. More than a dozen attorneys general have also urged the FTC to require delivery platforms to disclose data-driven pricing, and Congress has pressed major retailers on their practices. Companies should expect inquiries that combine pricing, privacy, and algorithmic accountability theories.

Litigation: Plaintiffs Target the Data Behind the Price

Because surveillance pricing is not broadly unlawful, plaintiffs are relying on adjacent frameworks: privacy and wiretap laws, consumer protection statutes, antitrust, and disclosure requirements. The theory in filed cases, to date, is rarely that personalization is illegal; it is that the data collection behind it was undisclosed, unauthorized or discriminatory. Recent cases include:

  • Airline tracking. In recently consolidated suits against JetBlue, plaintiffs allege tracking technologies collected data that informed fares. As the consolidated complaint puts it, “While surveillance pricing is not illegal in the United States, secretly collecting consumer data on the internet without adequate consent is illegal.”
  • Subscription pricing. In Blink v. WP Company, the plaintiff alleged a renewal email carried New York’s statutory notice while an AI model set each subscriber’s price at maximum willingness to pay, turning the disclosure into a roadmap for the claim. The plaintiff dismissed the action in fall 2026.
  • Algorithmic price-fixing. Thomas v. McDonald’s alleges a centralized “pricing engine” used franchisees’ pooled, nonpublic data to recommend prices in violation of the Sherman Act.

With increased attention in this space, this docket is likely to grow.

Practical Steps for Companies

Surveillance pricing touches legal, compliance, privacy, product and marketing teams. Businesses should consider the following steps:

  • Run the jurisdictional analysis. Assess obligations in New York, New Jersey, Maryland, Connecticut, and Seattle, track pending bills, and be ready to adapt or turn off features by jurisdiction.
  • Map the inputs and align disclosures. Identify what data actually drives pricing, and make sure privacy policies and any pricing notices describe that use accurately.
  • Test for proxy discrimination. Facially neutral combinations of inputs may correlate with protected characteristics, which Maryland’s law expressly targets.
  • Document, test and audit pricing tools. Treat pricing algorithms like other potentially high-risk systems, confirm they do not generate “compare-at” prices that fail reference-pricing rules, and keep records; Seattle requires three years of pricing records for covered businesses.
  • Diligence pricing vendors. Learn what data third-party tools collect, how they generate recommendations, and whether they pool nonpublic data from competitors.
  • Build personalization around loyalty and documented purposes. Document how programs fit potential carve-outs for enrolled loyalty programs, cost-justified differences, and publicly disclosed discounts, and use extra caution with groceries and other essentials.
  • Prepare for regulator inquiries. Whether or not a company received a 6(b) order, assume regulators may ask the same questions: what methodologies use personal data, what tests were run, and what consumers were told. Assemble those answers now, and watch for a final FTC policy statement, New York’s One Fair Price Act, and the Second Circuit’s decision concerning New York’s existing Algorithmic Pricing Disclosure Act.

The Bottom Line

We have seen this play out before. With junk fees, the FTC studied the practice, made the case publicly that consumers were being harmed, and then moved to regulate. Surveillance pricing is on the same track, and the October 6(b) orders, aimed directly at the companies setting prices, signal the next step. Businesses should expect a final FTC statement, more state and local bans, and more lawsuits that use companies’ own pricing disclosures as evidence.

Companies that can explain how their prices are set and what data goes into them will be in the strongest position when regulators or plaintiffs come asking.

References

Nat’l Retail Fed’n v. James, 806 F. Supp. 3d 427 (S.D.N.Y. 2025), appeal pending (2d Cir.).

In re JetBlue Surveillance Pricing Litigation, No. 1:26-cv-02405 (E.D.N.Y. filed October 23, 2026 and originally filed April 22, 2026);

Blink v. WP Co., No. 2026-CAB-004031 (D.C. Super. Ct. filed June 11, 2026 and dismissed September 28, 2026).

Thomas v. McDonald’s USA, LLC, No. 1:26-cv-12149 (N.D. Ill. filed Oct. 2, 2026).

FTC, Proposed Enforcement Policy Statement on Personalized Pricing (Aug. 19, 2026), Docket No. FTC-2026-1057.

Statement of FTC Chairman Andrew Ferguson (Aug. 19, 2026).

Press Release, FTC, FTC Issues Orders to Eight Companies Seeking Information on Surveillance Pricing (July 23, 2024).

Press Release, FTC, FTC Issues Orders to Nine Companies Seeking Information on Personalized Pricing (Oct. 28, 2026).

Press Release, FTC, FTC Surveillance Pricing Study Indicates Wide Range of Personal Data Used to Set Individualized Consumer Prices (Jan. 17, 2025).

Restore Online Shoppers’ Confidence Act, 15 U.S.C. §§ 8401–8405.

N.Y. Algorithmic Pricing Disclosure Act, N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law § 349-a.

N.Y. One Fair Price Act, S.8623-B/A.9349-B (2026).

N.Y.C. Council Int. No. 891-A, § 1 (proposed § 20-709.1) (passed by Council Nov. 12, 2026).

Md. Code Com. Law § 13-321 (HB 895, Protection From Predatory Pricing Act).

Conn. P.A. 26-130 (HB 5563).

N.J. P.L. 2026, c. 55 (A4085/A4523, Fair Price Protection Act).

N.J. A3497/S451 (2026) (FAIR Act).

Seattle, Wash., Ordinance 127515 (CB 121267), Fair Pricing and Transparency, Seattle Mun. Code ch. 7.35 (signed Oct. 5, 2026; effective Sept. 1, 2027).

California Department of Justice, Office of the Attorney General, On Data Privacy Day, Attorney General Bonta Focuses on Surveillance Pricing, Compliance with California Consumer Privacy Act (Jan. 27, 2026).

New York State Office of the Attorney General, Attorney General James Demands Answers from Instacart About Algorithmic Pricing (Jan. 8, 2026).

New York State Office of the Attorney General, Attorney General James Warns New Yorkers About Algorithmic Pricing as New Law Takes Effect (Nov. 5, 2025).

New York City Council, New York City Council Approves Landmark Legislation Banning Surveillance Pricing (Nov. 12, 2026).

Comments of the Retail Industry Leaders Association, FTC Docket No. 2026-1057 (Sept. 25, 2026).

Instacart, Instacart’s Pricing Principles: What We Stand For and What We’re Doing to Lower Your Grocery Bill (July 22, 2026).