AI and the Practice of Medicine: Examining Accountability and Responsibility in the AI Era
When does AI that assists a physician cross the line into AI that practices medicine? That question anchored a convening of the American Medical Association (AMA) and the Federation of State Medical Boards (FSMB) where physicians, state medical board leaders, health systems, developers, regulators and patient advocates confronted what may be the defining governance question of the AI era.
Manatt Health supported the planning and execution of the event and the resulting report, , which details the discussions that grappled with evolving clinical responsibilities, the role of state medical boards, regulatory approaches and the patient-physicians relationship.
Five Key Learnings:
- AI is already changing how medicine is practiced, but views differ on how quickly and to what extent it will transform clinical practice.
- As evidence emerges demonstrating that autonomous AI can effectively perform select clinical functions, the line between supporting and practicing medicine becomes critical for regulation and oversight.
- AI will redefine the physician’s role and transform how health care teams are organized and trained.
- Existing regulatory, licensure and liability frameworks were not designed for AI and need to be modernized.
- Patients are adopting AI faster than the health system is adapting.
Next Steps for Providers:
- Establish best practices for appropriate use of AI in clinical care: Establish the conditions under which AI can perform autonomously, what evidence should be required for adoption in clinical settings, and how organizations should safely deploy and monitor performance.
- Clarify the boundary between clinical technology and the practice of medicine: Define when AI functions as a clinical tool and when it constitutes the practice of medicine.
- Modernize oversight, accountability and liability frameworks: Establish how responsibility for AI-related patient harm should be assigned and clarify the roles of state medical boards, federal regulators, AI developers, physicians and other health care stakeholders.
- Prepare the physician and care team workforce: Adapt medical education, clinical training, continuing professional development and team-based care models to support responsible AI use.
- Preserve patient-centered care and trust: Develop best practices for integrating AI into care delivery in ways that are safe, transparent and equitable while strengthening the patient-physician relationship and upholding medical ethics.
Click to read the full report and recommendations.
For guidance on AI implementation and regulation at your organization, please contact , or .